This blog is now obsolete. Go to scott.arbeitman.id.au for all new content.

A Better Credit Card

| Sunday, July 6, 2008
It seems there are two extremes when it comes to credit cards. On the one hand, I have friends who refuse to apply for and use a credit card, claiming that they could potentially get themselves into some heavy deb quite quickly. On the other, there are those with a credit that has, err, some heavy debt.

There is middle ground of course. I use my credit card whenever I can because it makes financial sense. There are a few key reasons for this:
  • protection against online fraud
  • travel insurance
  • reduced car rental excess
  • protection if items are lost or stolen within 30 days of purchase
  • extended warranty
  • no interest or payments on purchases for up to 55 days
Depending on the specifics of your credit card, you'll have similar benefits. The last benefit is key. That means that if I spend within my means, I will make money using my credit card, since I can earn interest on the cash I would have otherwise used to make a purchase. I would estimate I earn about $100 a year on this fact alone, more than covering my card's annual fee. And I also benefit from the other features listed above.

So for those in this first category of people (who don't have a credit card), here's an idea for the banks. A hybrid credit/debit. It would work like this.
  • Up to 55 days interest free
  • Linked to a main savings account
  • Only allows purchases up to the value of the savings account
  • Each purchase moves cash from the savings account into an account where it is frozen but it earns interest
  • Payment is deducted automatically from this account when the credit card payment is due
  • Left over interest from this account is moved into the savings account every year
That would definitely work for me. Would it work for you?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Interest post Scott. Reminds me of the ANZ idea which rewards you (with those reward point things) for making repayments rather than spending.

I've just posted my thoughts on this along with examples of what might happen if you have a loan at the same time.

Scott Arbeitman said...

I was in a very banking mood, having spent several hours in the call centre of a large bank this weekend.

Ric Lamont said...

Hi Scott, not sure if this is what you're getting at, but there is a debit credit car available, if you don't mind the oxymoron.

For example, I have a Westpac Debit Mastercard linked to my savings account. For all intents and purposes it works as a mastercard (protection etc) but the funds come from your account, not the banks, so you're always in the black.

There are, however, no reward points, interest free periods etc, but it's free and lets you make online payments if you have an aversion to credit cards (as I do).

Ric

Scott Arbeitman said...

@Ric, the difference between what I'm proposing and a debit card is that the money won't be withrawn from your account immediately. Rather, it will be moved into a high interest savings account until the due date. That's not unlike a lot of people due with their credit cards anyways. I have a 55 day interest free credit card, and for those 55 days, my money sits in a savings account and is auto-debited when the bill is due.